By Aynsley Peet, Head of Growth at The Pixel

A recent survey of 1,000 UK online consumers conducted by The Pixel sheds new light on the key factors shaping user trust, satisfaction, and loyalty in today’s digital shopping experience.  One thing is clear from the findings: personalisation and loyalty are growing in importance.

Personalisation drives engagement

Online shoppers are increasingly drawn to brands that make them feel recognised and understood.

Nearly 44.3% of respondents said personalised shopping experiences are very or extremely important to them.

When asked what features add the most value to their online experience, shoppers highlighted:

• 67.1% – Targeted discounts or offers
• 46.9% – Personalised product recommendations
• 38.7% – Recently viewed items
• 27% – Reminders for items they may have forgotten
• 25% – Tailored homepages or category layouts
• 23% – Reminders to reorder frequently purchased items
• 14% – Abandoned basket emails

These insights show that consumers value personalisation that feels useful and rewarding and not just reactive. Rather than generic follow-ups, shoppers want meaningful, timely engagement that helps them find what they need faster or rewards them for their loyalty.

Loyalty fuels retention

Loyalty programmes continue to prove their worth.

More than 71% of respondents said they are likely or very likely to make repeat purchases if a brand offers a loyalty scheme.

This reinforces that value and recognition go hand in hand. Consumers are looking for more than just competitive pricing, they want to feel appreciated for their continued engagement.

Here’s how retailers can elevate personalisation from a buzzword to a business driver.

Start with a strategy, not just tools

Personalisation isn’t about plugging in a recommendation engine, it’s about understanding the why behind every interaction.

• Define personalisation goals (e.g., increasing repeat purchases, improving engagement, or boosting AOV).
• Map the customer journey to identify key touchpoints for relevant content, product suggestions, or offers.
• Align technology and data collection with measurable business outcomes.

A well-defined strategy helps personalisation feels intentional, consistent, and brand-aligned, rather than fragmented.

Build personalisation into design & UX

Personalisation can inform how an eCommerce experience is designed and delivered.

• Design modular layouts that adapt to user preferences or browsing history.
• Create dynamic content blocks on homepages and category pages.
• Optimise navigation, CTAs, and search based on user intent.

When design and technology work together, personalisation becomes seamless and invisible; the user simply experiences a site that feels intuitive and relevant.

Leverage technology partnerships

With the right stack, retailers can deliver more sophisticated personalisation at scale. That includes:

• Integrating CDPs (Customer Data Platforms) for unified user profiles.
• Using AI-powered personalisation engines
• Aligning marketing automation and CRM systems for consistent cross-channel experiences.

Measure, test, and iterate

Personalisation should evolve with customer expectations. Retailers should look to establish continuous optimisation cycles, including:

• A/B and multivariate testing for personalised experiences.
• Monitoring KPIs such as engagement, conversion rate, and retention.
• Refining tactics based on performance data and user feedback.

What worked last quarter may not work next season, staying agile ensures personalisation keeps pace with changing behaviours.

The takeaway for retailers

To stay competitive, brands can move beyond basic promotions and invest in personalised, data-informed experiences that build trust over time.

• Make personalisation strategic: Use customer insights to deliver offers and content that add value at every stage of the journey.
• Incentivise loyalty: Reward repeat purchases with exclusive benefits or early access.
• Focus on relevance, not noise: Customers can spot automation, authentic personalisation is what earns long-term loyalty.

Businesses that ignore these expectations risk losing customers to brands that make every interaction feel tailored, seamless, and rewarding.

In summary

Personalisation is no longer just about showing related products, it’s about creating meaningful connections. Loyalty isn’t just about discounts, it’s about recognition and trust.

Together, they define what modern consumers now consider true value.

Read another of The Pixel‘s most recent blogs with IMRG:

Why website performance defines digital success

Published 18/11/25